24. May 2012, 15:43:03
Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
1 Hour
1 Day
1 Week
1 Month
Forever
Login with username, password and session length
Home
Forum
Help
Contact
Search
Calendar
Login
Register
PayPal Donations
Donations of any size and regularity are always welcome to help offset the costs of maintaining this site.
Recent
Silver Larl Rules, RP Standards, & Other Info
by
Druhsus
[
Today
at 15:05:48]
Making being a slave a lil easier and lil more fun
by
Jules Jierdon
[
Today
at 14:55:37]
Not sure how this family story will end...
by
Druhsus
[
Today
at 14:28:57]
The Return of Silver Larl
by
Gorm
[
Today
at 08:54:30]
Visitors bringing an interesting offer
by
Conall DeCuir
[
Today
at 08:16:01]
GCM Meter
by
Randall Reich
[
Today
at 07:08:03]
Lets Get Creative : RP Cooking
by
Sayrax wiefel
[
Today
at 06:40:49]
To Hug or not to Hug
by
Jessie Spiritweaver
[
Today
at 03:19:56]
Longhall Hospitality
by
Jessie Spiritweaver
[
Today
at 02:51:27]
Membershhip Standards
by
Jessie Spiritweaver
[
Today
at 02:49:03]
Articles
Welcome to GOR-SL
by
Laja DeCuir
... latest news and developments
by
Laja DeCuir
Just some thoughts...
by
Laja DeCuir
Calendar
May 2012
Su
Mo
Tu
We
Th
Fr
Sa
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
______ Holidays ______
May 28
- Memorial Day
links one shouldn't miss
Gor SL
>
Forum
>
About the world of GOR
>
Out of the books
(Moderator:
Laja DeCuir
) >
Free Women Wielding Axes
Pages: [
1
]
2
3
...
6
Go Down
« previous
next »
Print
Author
Topic: Free Women Wielding Axes (Read 4004 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Eternity Starsmith
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 420
Free Women Wielding Axes
«
04. October 2011, 05:11:03 »
I'm reading Magicians of Gor at the moment and this one thing pretty much stopped me in my tracks:
"Once in Ar, several years ago, several free women, in their anger at slaves, and perhaps jealous of the pleasures of masters and slaves, entered a paga tavern with clubs and axes, seeking to destroy it."
OooooOo.
So. Free women in a city raiding a tavern armed with axes, no less. Axes! Not only that but it's described as rare but "not unprecedented". Any comments about this? I always have had the impression that would be unthinkable. In the book, the free women are disarmed and bound but nonetheless, they did it. They became slaves. I gotta say, what a glorious way to become a slave.
«
Last Edit: 04. October 2011, 05:11:50 by Eternity Starsmith
»
Logged
Rayzor McAuley
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 1217
Re: Free Women Wielding Axes
«
04. October 2011, 05:13:16 »
There are many different things that qualify as an axe. I'm sure what they had would be more akin to a hatchet than the bearded great axes of Torvaldsland.
«
Last Edit: 04. October 2011, 05:14:11 by Rayzor McAuley
»
Logged
The absence of proof is no proof of absence.
Eternity Starsmith
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 420
Re: Free Women Wielding Axes
«
04. October 2011, 05:16:59 »
If I ever decide to become a slave again, I'm going out in style.
Logged
Anarch
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 346
Warbringer
Re: Free Women Wielding Axes
«
04. October 2011, 05:32:21 »
I personally seriously wonder where this entire concept comes from that Free Women can't lift a man's sword or axe, because it supposedly would be too heavy. Seems to be something that a small part of the male population in BtB Gor likes to keep enforced, similar to the "I can only be dragged by 2-3 women"-rule...
If the situation calls for it... Let them pick up a sword or a battle-axe and RP it out. Or do it in combat even... although I guess the men that can't be arsed to raise their meter pew pew skills would have objections with that. Insta-invincible man and all that...
Plenty of examples in the books of FW or slaves picking up a weapon they really shouldn't have to defend themselves or attack someone. The most known one Talena cutting of a man's hand with a sword. The less known one Poala in Beasts of Gor simply stabbing a man in the arm (who oddly enough in return was too scared to be angry at Poala for it... (Talk about ungorean behaviour of men in the books ...)).
Logged
"Civilized men, the small and pale, the righteous, the learned, the smug, the supercilious, the weak-stomached and contemptuous, stand upon the shoulders of forgotten, bloody giants."
(Beasts of Gor, p.31)
Rayzor McAuley
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 1217
Re: Free Women Wielding Axes
«
04. October 2011, 06:08:16 »
It's very obvious to anyone who has read even the first book that a woman may be able to pick up a sword and use it, but that is a far cry from being proficient at it. It really has little to do with the ability to lift the weapon, but the ability to use it effectively. Free Women on Gor did not receive weapons training. That's why I think that the mob of women most likely picked up things that were handy. Anything from a heavy stick to a 2 x 4 could constitute a club. An axe can be the size of a camping hatchet, tomahawk, or fire axe.
The problem in SL Gor, and the reason that many BtB sims implement such rules, is that there are many women who are Xena all of a sudden if given the opportunity to swing long swords and great axes, which is highly implausible in an authentic Gor environment. Sure, you can make the argument that men need to hone their clicker finger to be dominant
, but what you've never seemed to understand is that there is so much more to Gor than meter combat.
«
Last Edit: 04. October 2011, 06:10:42 by Rayzor McAuley
»
Logged
The absence of proof is no proof of absence.
Xaz Elephas
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 2528
Re: Free Women Wielding Axes
«
04. October 2011, 06:17:11 »
Awhile back there was a chat about weapons and there weight. I googled anciet sword... medievil swords, spears, axes... and was very surprised to learn they were not very heavey at all. I am not going to google it again but maybe someone can and post the weights here.
«
Last Edit: 04. October 2011, 12:58:41 by Xaz Elephas
»
Logged
I'm the dude playing the dude disguised as another dude. Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit on his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin to slit throats.
Sayrax wiefel
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 1286
Re: Free Women Wielding Axes
«
04. October 2011, 06:57:55 »
Good swords were light, agile, well balanced, and though fairly stiff, still flexible and resilient. They were killing tools and their study should be approached from that understanding. A sword's weight cannot be judged just from its size or blade width. Thus, while the weight of Medieval and Renaissance swords can be accurately recorded and compiled, the matter of their being "heavy" or not is one of perspective. It is clear that despite the facts, regardless of the objective mass of historical swords, their "heaviness" is a subjective matter. The same three-pound weapon is elegant and robust to a skilled practitioner while his desk-bound colleague might think it ungainly and sluggish. The understanding we must have is that to the men who skillfully used these tools, they weighed just right.
Table One
Date(aprox) Length Weight Origin Wt/Lgth Source
(lb/oz) (lb/ft)
9th-10th c. 30 1/8" 2/8 Scand? 1.0 Wallace
1150-1200 32 3/8" 2/10 German .97 Wallace
13th c. 33 3/8" 1/8 .53 Wallace
1340 33 3/4" 2/9 French? .98 Wallace
1375-1400 30" 3/0 French 1.2 Wallace
14th c. 29 3/8" 2/1 .84 Wallace
1350-1400 29 3/16" 3/3 French 1.31 Wallace
1375-1400 23 5/8" * 2/8 1.27 Wallace
1380 31 1/8" 2/1 .8 Wallace
1400 34 3/8" 2/12 .96 Wallace
1460 34 3/4" 2/15 Italian? 1.01 Wallace
early 16th c. 36 1/8" 3/2 German 1.04 Wallace
9th-10th c. 75.5 cm. .5 Kg. Nordic .44 Wagner
9th-11th c? 89.5 cm. 1.42 Kg. 1.06 Wagner
11th-13th c. 92 cm. 1 Kg. Prague? .73 Wagner
Before 1432 41" 1/11 Italian? .49 Tower
about 1480 43.2" 2/12 German? .76 Tower (Hand and a half?)
about 1500 35.4" 1/15 Swiss .66 Tower
or Swabian
* Aproximately 5" of tip missing
c. means century.
Table Two: Shields and Bucklers
Date(aprox) Size Weight Origin Wt/Area
(lb/oz) (lb/sq ft)
Leather Targets for Parade
1560 22 1/2 " 5/2.5 Italian 1.9
1560 22 11/16" 5/8 Italian 2.0
1560 22 3/16" 5/14 Italian 2.2
Wooden Pageant Shields
1580 22 5/8" 4/6 Italian 1.6
1590 18 27/32" 3/10.5 Italian 1.9
Wooden Bucklers
1600 17 1/2" 3/7 German 2.1
1600 20 3/4" 3/3 Italian? 1.4
Steel Bucklers
16th c. 15 1/2" 4/9 Italian 3.5
1600 21 1/4" 7/3.5 Italian 2.9
Steel "Shield or Bucklers"
1560 23 3/8" 9/4 Span/Ger 3.1
1560 22 1/4" 7/14 Italian 2.9
1580 22 1/4" 12/4 Italian 4.5
Steel "Pageant Shields or Bucklers"
16th c. 21 3/8" 7/1 Flem/Fr 2.8
16th c. 24 7/16" 9/.5 Flem/Fr 2.8
1570 24 7/8" 6/9.5 Ger/Fl 2.0
1590 22 7/32" 8/12.5 German 3.3
1560 23 1/8" 9/0 Italian 3.1
1560 23" 8/1 Italian 2.8
1570 21 3/4" 7/4.5 Italian 2.8
1570 22 1/2" 7/1.5 Italian 2.6
1570 22 1/4" 9/3.5 Italian 3.4
1580-1600 23" 7/4 Italian 2.5
Post 1556 22 3/4" 10/4.5 Italian 3.9
1580 19 1/2" 7/1 Italian 3.4
1590 22 3/16" 7/7.5 Italian 2.8
1590 23 1/2" 8/2 Italian 2.7
1620 23 3/8" 10/14 Ger/Fl 3.6
Average of Historical Shields is 2.75 lb/sq ft, which corresponds to a 24" round weighing 8lb 10 oz.
A.S. XVI 24" 10/0 Caid Minimum 3.2
A.S. XVI 24" 8/0 Illegal 2.5
A.S. XVI 24" 6/0 Illegal 1.9
Note: Some of the shields were slightly oval; the average radius is shown. The last three shields are given for purposes of comparison.
Table Three: Maces
Date(aprox) Length Weight Origin
(lb/oz)
1470 15.5"* 2/12 South German
1560 17 1/16"** 3/11 Milanese
1560 22 1/16" 2/14.5 North Italian
1540 25 3/4" 3/5 Italian
1540 25" 3/3.75 Italian
1550 23 4/5" 2/12.75 Italian(?)
1550 25" 3/6 German
1580 17 3/4"** 4/1.5 Milanese
1560 18 15/16"** 3/6.5 Milanese
*From the guard
**Haft
Table Four: Rapiers
Date (aprox) Length Weight Origin Wt/Lgth
(lb/oz) (lb/ft)
1590 46 5/8" 3/4.5 Italian(?) 0.845
1600 41 1/2" 2/13 German 0.813
1585 43 5/8" 2/5.5 Italian (Milan) 0.645
1600 39.5" 2/4.5 German 0.693
1590 42 3/8" 3/5.5 North Italian 0.947
1590 43 3/8" 3/2 Italian 0.865
1570-1600 47 7/8" 3/6.5 Italian 0.854
1600 42 13/16" 3/5 Italain 0.928
1600 44 7/8" 3/1 Italian 0.819
1590 41 1/4" 2/13 Italian 0.818
1580-1600 41 1/4" 2/13.5 Spanish (Toledo) 0.827
1600 40 1/4" 2/9.5 Italian (Brescia) 0.773
1600 45 7/8" 2/9.5 Italian(?) 0.678
1600 41 3/4" 2/7 Italian (Milan) 0.701
1550-1600 44 3/8" 3/2 Italian (Milan) 0.845
1600 44 5/8" 2/15.5 Italian (Milan) 0.798
1600 41 3/16" 3/9.5 German 1.05
Average Wt/Lgth: 0.82
Table Five: Two-Handed Swords
Date (aprox) Length Weight Origin Wt/Lgth
Blade Grip Over all (lb/oz) (lb/ft)
Mid 16th c 50 1/4" 23 3/4" 74" 8/6 German 1.36
1580 58 3/4" 19 5/8" 78 3/8" 14/3 German 2.
1580 50 1/8" 13 1/2" 63 5/8" 7/4 German 1.37
1500-10 44 5/8" 14 3/4" 59 3/8" 5/6.5 Italian 1.09
1530 48" 16 1/2" 64 1/2" 6/10 Italian 1.23
16th c. 53 1/4" 16" 69 1/4" 5/14 Spanish or German 1.02
early 16th c. 46 1/8" 17 5/8" 63 3/4" 6/6 German 1.2
Table Six: Halberds etc.
Date (aprox) Length Weight Origin Type Source
(lb/oz)
late 14th-
early 15th c. 14 3/4"* 4/8 Swiss Hallberd Wallace
1500 16 1/4"* 4/7 German Hallberd Wallace
1593 23 1/2"* 6/10 German Hallberd Wallace
1580-1620** 31 5/8"* 7/4.5 Saxon Hallberd Wallace
1600-1620 21 1/8"* 5/5 Saxon Hallberd Wallace
about 1500 70" 6/7 European Pollaxe Tower
about 1500 97" 9/1 European Glaive Tower Modern Haft
1500-1550 93.5" 7/11 European Pollaxe Tower Iron butt spike
early 16th c. 83.12" 4/12 Italian Partizan Tower Modern Haft
early 16th c. 100.75" 4/0 Italian? Partizan Tower Modern Haft
early 16th c. 91.5" 5/14 Italian Halberd Tower Haft not original
16th c. 80.5" 5/1 English Bill Tower Modern Haft
early 16th c. 85.5" 9/15 Italian Bill Tower Modern Haft
about 1600 80.37" 4/7 Italian? Partizan Tower
* The head, in some cases including the socket. Four 17th c. halberds are listed with shafts. The overall lengths are 60 5/8, 85, 90, and 75.5 . The first is listed as an officer's halberd, and the fourth as a "Halberd or Pole-Axe."
** There are 12 of these, "Carried by the Guard of the Elector of Saxony; all of one pattern but differing slightly in details."
[Published in Crown Prints,
Logged
After all, Goreans are only human.
Guardsman of Gor Book 16 Page 106
Eternity Starsmith
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 420
Re: Free Women Wielding Axes
«
04. October 2011, 08:36:12 »
Quote from: Rayzor McAuley on 04. October 2011, 06:08:16
It's very obvious to anyone who has read even the first book that a woman may be able to pick up a sword and use it, but that is a far cry from being proficient at it. It really has little to do with the ability to lift the weapon, but the ability to use it effectively. Free Women on Gor did not receive weapons training. That's why I think that the mob of women most likely picked up things that were handy. Anything from a heavy stick to a 2 x 4 could constitute a club. An axe can be the size of a camping hatchet, tomahawk, or fire axe.
The problem in SL Gor, and the reason that many BtB sims implement such rules, is that there are many women who are Xena all of a sudden if given the opportunity to swing long swords and great axes, which is highly implausible in an authentic Gor environment. Sure, you can make the argument that men need to hone their clicker finger to be dominant
, but what you've never seemed to understand is that there is so much more to Gor than meter combat.
Here's more to the quote:
Once in Ar, several years ago, several free women, in their anger at slaves, and perhaps jealous of the pleasures of masters and slaves, entered a paga tavern with clubs and axes, seeking to destroy it. This is, I believe, and example, though a rather extreme one, of a not unprecedented sort of psychological reaction, the attempt, by disparagement or action, motivated by envy, jealousy, resentment, or such, to keep from others pleasures which one oneself is unable, or unwilling, to enjoy. In any event, as a historical note, the men in the tavern, being Gorean, and thus not being inhibited or confused by negativistic, antibiological traditions, quickly disarmed the women. They then stripped them, bound their hands behind their back, put them of a neck rope, and, by means of switches, conducted them swiftly outside the tavern. The women were then, outside the tavern, on the bridge of twenty lanterns, forced to witness the burning of their garments. They were then permitted to leave, though still bound and in coffle. Gorean men do not surrender their birthright as males, their rightful dominance,their appropriate mastery. They do not choose to be dictated to by females.
The reason I re-posted the quote in lengthier detail is to point out that Norman makes the comparison of Earth men to Gorean men. Every man here, by default, is an Earth man trying to roleplay a Gorean man. Earth men, according to Norman (who seems to have a real contempt for all of you) would be inhibited and confused by a female attack of the kind described here. An Earth man, we might speculate, might not know what to do. He might stumble back, doubt himself, and let the free women take over. A Gorean man, on the other hand, is different. He makes a conscious
choice
to disallow the attacking free women to succeed in their task. What this infers is that the Gorean free women could indeed pick up axes and clubs and dominate men with them; they could succeed or at least they thought they could. However, because the Gorean men choose to master them, because they are Gorean and not of Earth, then the free women fail and become slaves. Norman hints that perhaps the free women unconsciously wished to be slaves all along:
Needless to say, in time, the free women, learning the suitable roles and lessons of womanhood, for which they had genetic predispositions, and aided by their lovely tutors, were permitted to petition for the collar. It was granted to them. It seems that this was what they had wanted all the time, though on a level not fully comprehensible to them at the beginning.
Untrained or not, a pack of axe-wielding women might present a problem for men. Surely she can swing the axe and surely it is sharp. Many people who murder each other with weapons on Earth aren't trained. They simply pick up the weapon and hack and slash whomever they end up killing. So, I think it can be assumed that the free women attacking the tavern may indeed have a chance at success despite any lack of weapons training or fighting skills, particularly if the men are drunk or otherwise engaged with naked females.
In Norman's world, the whole point is that the women fail and become slaves. Otherwise, Norman wouldn't have had anything jack off to while he wrote.
But think about it. Isn't it sort of ridiculous for a man to expect a woman to limit her attack, to not put her entire being into her assault toward him? But, but, but... Many men sure do whine a lot about Xena warriors in Gor. It's the man's responsibility to rise to the challenge. An Earth man, in my opinion, will sit around and whine about technicalities; a Gorean man would simply make himself a better fighter.
Lastly, I suppose, I hear a lot of people complain about fighting in terms of who is the faster clicker and how that does not equate to better swordsmanship in the real world (Gor). In other words, the mind behind the computer is not the same as the physical strength in person. A woman can have a sharp mind and without the handicap of being physically weaker, she may outrageously and scandalously embody the so-called Xena warrior princess archetype. We know Norman wouldn't have it that way. However, on the other hand, if a man doesn't have certain skills in the virtual world in fighting, e.g. a fast finger, then chances are he would be fairly uncoordinated with a weapon in physical reality as well. I honestly think John Norman might just say such a male is an Earth male, not a Gorean male.
So therein lies the rub. In order for Earth males to successfully roleplay Gorean males, as described in the books, the trend is to require roleplayers playing females to limit themselves. You get labeled Xena warrior princess if you put your full passion into fighting. You are frowned upon. Fingers waggle. And yet, any panther or insane free woman with an axe surely put all of her passion and more into her assault on Gorean men, who then turned around and dominated and enslaved her. So why is it that female roleplayers must sacrifice such passion so that male roleplayers don't have to hone their "clicking fingers"? Why is it that male roleplayers (not all) often permit themselves to be lazy and expect female roleplayers to limit their character's passion and hand them their goodies on a silver platter? I can tell you straight up I respect a man more who says something along the lines of "If I lose, I'm going to train my ass off until I win" vs. a red caste warrior who complains that females are too empowered but the only thing he seems to shoot is the breeze.
«
Last Edit: 04. October 2011, 08:49:11 by Eternity Starsmith
»
Logged
Darkangel Mavendorf
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 151
Re: Free Women Wielding Axes
«
04. October 2011, 10:30:31 »
"The strength of a full-grown woman is equivalent to a twelve-year old boy." (Tribesman of Gor, p.223)
The books give examples showing the inferiority of the strength of women. Even the strongest of Gorean women is seen to be the inferior of the average Gorean man. In Tribesman of Gor, there is a masculine female slave who terrorized the rest of the kajirae. Yet, she was beaten by an ordinary male slave, not even a fighting slave. Mercenaries of Gor explains about a strong woman who no other woman could take a piece of bread from. It was stated that any man could have easily taken the bread from her.
"She was a large girl, and formidable to us, but, compared to the men, she was only another female, no different from us. Compared to them, her size and strength, really only that of a woman, was, like ours, when all was said and done, simply negligible. Compared to them she was, like us simply small and weak. Before them, and to them, she could never be any more than we, only another female, small, lovely and helpless, a mere female, totally at their mercy." (Dancer of Gor, p.107)
These statements apply to all men and not just warriors. The average Gorean man, of any caste, is stronger than any Gorean woman.
"It is nothing for a man to overpower a female." (Tribesman of Gor, p.143).
"The insignia of men," become empty mockeries when permitted to women." (Mercenaries of Gor, p.56)
enough said?
Logged
Anarch
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 346
Warbringer
Re: Free Women Wielding Axes
«
04. October 2011, 10:40:45 »
4 one-liners out of 30 books don't really cut it when there's entire chapters commited to women wielding spears and swords (the several female mercenaries that were mentioned in Beasts of Gor and Tribesmen of Gor). Funny part is how Tarl, got subdued and captured both times by both of them... and then gets his ass whipped.
Above along with the other examples I gave earlier of women attacking men with swords...
There's a certain amount of lunacy involved in BtB Gor to express the same 3-4 quotes to state that a woman would never win a fight against a man... considering Tarl tended to get his ass kicked multiple times by those women. (Captured by panthers, female mercenaries...) The same Tarl who sometimes managed to kill several Warriors or Assassins in a row in direct combat...
Logged
"Civilized men, the small and pale, the righteous, the learned, the smug, the supercilious, the weak-stomached and contemptuous, stand upon the shoulders of forgotten, bloody giants."
(Beasts of Gor, p.31)
Daved Calderwood
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 925
Re: Free Women Wielding Axes
«
04. October 2011, 12:10:26 »
Quote from: Anarch on 04. October 2011, 10:40:45
4 one-liners out of 30 books don't really cut it when there's entire chapters commited to women wielding spears and swords (the several female mercenaries that were mentioned in Beasts of Gor and Tribesmen of Gor). Funny part is how Tarl, got subdued and captured both times by both of them... and then gets his ass whipped.
Above along with the other examples I gave earlier of women attacking men with swords...
There's a certain amount of lunacy involved in BtB Gor to express the same 3-4 quotes to state that a woman would never win a fight against a man... considering Tarl tended to get his ass kicked multiple times by those women. (Captured by panthers, female mercenaries...) The same Tarl who sometimes managed to kill several Warriors or Assassins in a row in direct combat...
But wasn't that due to where these women were located and what clans they roamed with? I totally agree with the fact that there had to have been women that were skilled with weapons and I guess due to the circumstances had to wield them against men. By the same token I could see how this would not have gone over with the rest of Gor in a bunch of cities. The idea of giving a free woman the training to use a sword fir example would be a hard sell to pretty much any gorean man.
Ok so lets look at this OOC a moment. I don't consider the fact that women not being allowed to use swords or wield weapons against men something of "lunacy". This isn't to slam GE sims but let's face it we start letting this go down like it's a cool thing then we run the risk of letting a few more things go by until we have a watered down version of what looks like by the book. I used to be an outlaw and we had female outlaws there as well and at first having the extra muscle was cool but damn it wasn't as the books made it or it least not close to the spirit of the books.
Look at it this way, for a female to be a Black Caste would be the single most ingenious concept. She would be the last person anyone would expect to be a threat and the last anyone would suspect to have killed someone. She could get in and out of places just being disguised as a regular free woman and the guards wouldn't give her a second thought. But it's not in the books and that's because the Black Caste would have killed her ass faster than the mark she was after. Same goes for the Red Caste, you know they would sooner jump off a cliff than allow a woman to wield a sword and defend the city, it just wasn't done.
About the only quote I have found to be absolutely stupid is the notion that a woman has the strength of a twelve or fourteen old boy. That is total bullshit because physically that just isn't possible that every woman in the gene pool are that weak. Oh and let me get this straight, you get some earth woman who was an aerobics trainer , she lands in Gor and now she is weaker than a kid? Come on! To me that's just Norman's way of ensuring that the females in his world could never be able to rise up against men. From the books it seems that the only women that have half a chance are panthers and look what he does to them. They are outcasts , there is something wrong with alot of them that they have chosen their personal freedom over any sort of domination of men. So of course they are a little stronger but Norman of course launches their asses deep in the forest where they are sometimes seen and the men they capture are "weak men" or outlaws.
From a social standpoint I think it could be possible that there were women out there who knew how to fight but that wouldn't be the norm in the more "civilized" places because no man would allow it. As far as physically not being able to do it I have trouble wrapping my head around that.
Logged
http://goreanstories.wordpress.com/
Anarch
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 346
Warbringer
Re: Free Women Wielding Axes
«
04. October 2011, 12:21:39 »
I'm not saying it should be standard, especially not in the southern cities, for FW to walk around as if they're guards or warriors, although some exceptions should be possible imo.
I'm more bothered with the general attitude of starting to throw an OOC hissyfit as soon as a single FW with a weapon shows up on a BtB sim. There is generally nothing wrong at all with a single armed woman, or a single female mercenary.
A long time ago, a woman asked to become a mercenary in Minus, a generally rather lawless place that I could see not upholding 'too much standards'. And to me, considering that most mercenaries tended to be mostly a bunch of thugs or outlaws who just wanted to earn extra coin and loot from raiding, it felt somewhat in place for her to RP that role. I obviously also understand all the other complications such a thing would bring along so I can't blame people not wanting to have something like that on their sim, however... the RP to me felt authentic and in accordance with the books. And I still believe that single mercenary women are in accordance with the books. Especially if they are not very skilled meter fighters, or tend to uphold the standards of avoiding to win fights against men.
Entire roaming armies of them is another matter, but it's something I'm willing to look through the fingers, simply because I feel there is more acceptance for conflict RP and the overall grittiness of the books in GE Gor. But that aside as it's a bit off-topic.
What becomes even more annoying to me are tied up guys that start complaining that a FW can't disarm them from their weapons because they're supposedly too weak to pick up weapons. (Rubbish ofcourse since a lot of examples are in the books of FW wielding swords, and even a slave-girl).
Logged
"Civilized men, the small and pale, the righteous, the learned, the smug, the supercilious, the weak-stomached and contemptuous, stand upon the shoulders of forgotten, bloody giants."
(Beasts of Gor, p.31)
Xaz Elephas
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 2528
Re: Free Women Wielding Axes
«
04. October 2011, 13:06:56 »
Last week a FW shows up on the sim. She had a crossbow on her back. I could have done the Im and said ‘... um we don't allow FW to have weapons here like bows, sword, axes…’ but I decided what the heck let me engage her in role-play and see what happens. So I did and in the role-play it came out why she had the weapon and I got to say it was very creative and plausible. Her role-play explanation was really good and I enjoyed the interaction with her. At no time did I draw my weapon nor did she. She role-played being timed about running into a Black Caste. Point being sometimes before you so quickly Im someone ooc and toss a rule at them, take a chance, role-play... see what the story might be. What do you got to loose? I learned something that day; from now on I won’t be so quick to judge someone might be breaking a rule. I will engage them and see what there story is first.
Logged
I'm the dude playing the dude disguised as another dude. Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit on his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin to slit throats.
Carter Ebbage
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 3205
Re: Free Women Wielding Axes
«
04. October 2011, 13:28:37 »
This is where the fundamental issue of women with weapons becomes clouded and distorted between the actual behaviour of women in SL GOR and weapons and the actual basic premis of gorean women and weapons.
So step back... there use to be hoardes of women running around SL GOR like huge armies on the move. They called themselves Captain, Commander, General etc etc... these where not gorean Free Women.. these were women wanting to fight and create large groups to take on cities and men.
It also became the norm that when warriors attacked a city.. suddenly the whole population of slaves, Free Women of every caste armed themselves in addittion to the men that happened to be there.. it was crazy !!!
It became so stupid that an encounter with a woman claiming to be from Earth and she was playing being a Colonel in the US Marine Corps and therefore could kick my butt with her martial arts and plethora of weapons on her back, made me decide enough was enough and I joined the BTB theme.
So dont confuse any rationale debate and quotes from books ... BTB was simply a way of stopping Lara Croft and her armies.
Logged
"Lo Carter," said he, "Rarius. Civitatis Trevis."
dana Tehani
Hero Member
Offline
Posts: 3312
Re: Free Women Wielding Axes
«
04. October 2011, 17:04:11 »
Quote from: Xaz Elephas on 04. October 2011, 13:06:56
Last week a FW shows up on the sim. She had a crossbow on her back. I could have done the Im and said ‘... um we don't allow FW to have weapons here like bows, sword, axes…’ but I decided what the heck let me engage her in role-play and see what happens. So I did and in the role-play it came out why she had the weapon and I got to say it was very creative and plausible. Her role-play explanation was really good and I enjoyed the interaction with her. At no time did I draw my weapon nor did she. She role-played being timed about running into a Black Caste. Point being sometimes before you so quickly Im someone ooc and toss a rule at them, take a chance, role-play... see what the story might be. What do you got to loose? I learned something that day; from now on I won’t be so quick to judge someone might be breaking a rule. I will engage them and see what there story is first.
well done Xaz xx dealing with things IC is the best way to go (most the time!)
Logged
Honesty is the key to a relationship.
If you can fake that, you're in!
Pages: [
1
]
2
3
...
6
Go Up
Print
« previous
next »
Jump to:
Please select a destination:
-----------------------------
About the world of GOR
-----------------------------
=> Out of the books
=> Castes and Roles
===> Caste of Initiates
===> Caste of Scribes
===> Caste of Physicians
===> Caste of Builders
===> Caste of Warriors
===> Caste of Merchants
=====> Caste of Slavers
===> Caste of Assassins - the BC
===> Caste of Thieves
===> Panther Girls
===> She-Urts
===> Beggars
=> Gorean Lifestyle/r
-----------------------------
Gorean Roleplay
-----------------------------
=> Gorean Role Play - General Discussions
=> RP Logs
=> RP Stories
===> Larp Adventures
=> RP Review and Feedback
-----------------------------
Gorean Events
-----------------------------
=> Fairs, Dances, Celebrations....
-----------------------------
Gorean SIMs in Second Life
-----------------------------
=> Algron
===> Algron Roleplays
===> Algron Suggestions comments and complaints
===> Algron Events and future planning
===> Algron Slaves Free form discussion
===> Algron Free Discussion
=> The Elysium of Gor
=> City of Harfax
===> Harfax - OOC Discussions
===> Harfax - RP Stories
=> Hochburg
===> Hochburg - Roleplays
===> Hochburg - Events
===> Hochburg - General discussions
=> Isle of Landa
=> Fortress of Maelstorm
===> Maelstrom - General Discussions
===> Maelstrom - RP and story lines
===> Maelstrom - Events
=> Oasis of the Red Scimitar
=> Port Cos Community Forum
===> Port Cos Green Caste
===> Port Cos Blue Caste
===> Port Cos Scarlets
===> Port Cos Merchants
===> Port Cos Slaves
=> Rive de Bois
===> Village of Rive de Bois
===> Sa Shima Panther Girls
=> Silver Larl
===> Silver Larl - Rules, RP Standards, & Other Info
===> Silver Larl - General Discussion
===> Silver Larl - Role Play
===> Silver Larl - Introduce yourself
=> Tarnwald - Introduction, Laws and Council Decisions
===> High Castes of Tarnwald
===> Rarii of Tarnwald
===> Low Castes of Tarnwald
===> Kennel of Tarnwald
===> Citizen Meetings
===> Daily Saphronicus
===> Tarnwald Events
=> Tarn's Rest General Discussions
===> Tarn's Rest Warrior's Hall
===> Tarn's Rest Events
===> Tarn's Rest Role-play
===> Former Postings (Ka'Zahr)
=> The Road to Brundisium – Information on Laws, Council Decisions and Events
===> The Road to Brundisium Events
===> The Road to Brundisium Merchant's Market
=> City of Thentis
===> RP Stories & Logs
===> Thentis Warriors
===> Thentis Merchants
===> Thentis Slaves
===> Thentis Special Events
=> The City of Treve - Introduction, Laws and Council Decisions
===> Treve Role Play
===> Treve Tribune
===> Warriors of Treve
===> The Ludus of Treve
===> Gorean Training Academy
===> Kennel of Treve
===> Treve Events
=> The Village of Dyval
===> Dyval - General Discussion
===> Dyval - Events
===> Dyval - RP Stories and Logs
===> Dyval - Character Intros
===> Dýr Kona Band
=> The Village of Sais
===> Sais Recruiting
===> Sais Sim Rules
===> Sais RP Stories & Logs
===> Sais Events
=> The Voltai Crags
===> The Gorean Coin Exchange
===> Riverwood Crier
===> Castra Darkthorn Assassins
=====> Castra Darkthorn Kajira
=====> Castra Darkthorn In Character
=====> Castra Darkthorn Black Court Petition Forum
=> Wood Haven-Forest Port - General Discussion
===> Wood Haven-Forest Port - RP Stories
===> Wood Haven-Forest Port - Village Discussion
===> Wood Haven-Forest Port - Warriors
===> Wood Haven-Forest Port - Events
=> ....more different gorean SIMs
=> The Black Caste Assassin's Group
===> Black Caste IC Forum
===> Black Caste Kajira
===> Black Caste Assassin Trainee
=> Black Daggers
=> The Black Kaiila - Introduction, Laws and rules
===> The Black Kaiila - General discussions
===> Black Kaiila RP
=> Teslik & Sip Root
===> RP Logs of Teslik & Sip Root Physicians
-----------------------------
Miscellaneous
-----------------------------
=> Questions, requests or critique about GOR-SL
=> Technical Stuff
=> Gossip
=> Introduce yourself....
=> Shops, new releases of gorean goods
=> RLF - Relay for Life 2012 Gorean Team
-----------------------------
Trash
-----------------------------
===> Panther Wilds
=====> RP Stories and Logs
=====> Events
===> Laura
=====> IC and Storylines
=====> OOC and Events
===> Village of Jula
=====> Village of Jula Town Crier
=====> Village of Jula Back Ally
===> The Road to Brundisium - Warriors Hall
===> The Black Lodge
=====> The Black Lodge - Announcements
=====> The Black Lodge - Roleplay Journals
=====> Assassins of the Black Lodge
===> Torchwood Village - A BTB Gorean RP Sim
=====> Torchwood Villagers
=====> Torchwood RP Stories
=====> Torchwood Events
===> The Village of Yggdrasil
=====> Yggdrasil Feedback and Ideas
=====> Yggdrasil Roleplay/Storylines
=====> Yggdrasil Villagers
=====> Yggdrasil Events
=====> Torvaldsland Academy
===> Fina ~ Vosk River Region
=====> Introduction to Fina
=====> Fina Roleplay
=====> Fina Events
=====> Vosk Spirit - Fina Publication
=====> Citizens and Property of Fina
===> Corcyrus
=====> Corcyrus - Events
=====> Corcyrus - Community Forum
=====> Corcyrus Residents
=====> Corcyrus - Caste Forum
===> Farnacium - Free BTB Merchant Island
=====> Farnacium Rules
=====> Farnacium History
=====> Farnacium Events
=====> Farnacium Economy
=====> Farnacium Recruiting
===> City of Cyprianus
=====> RP stories & logs
=====> General Discussions
=====> Events
===> Teletus- Introduction, Rules and Senate decisions
=====> Teletus - Events
=====> Teletus - Plots and rumors
=====> Kennel of Teletus
===> Tafa Trading Post
=====> Tafa - General Discussions
=====> Tafa - IC stories and logs
=====> Tafa - Characters Backgrounds
=====> Tafa - Events
===> Rarn, City of Copper
=====> Rarn News
=====> Rarn Events
=====> Rarn Rp
===> Forest Port
=====> Lar Torvis
=====> Domus of Novus Orsa
=======> Domus of Novus Orsa - Slaver's Office
=======> Domus of Novus Orsa - Events
=======> Domus of Novus Orsa - General Chat/RP
=====> The Brigand
===> The City of Venna - Community Forum
=====> The City of Venna - Events
=====> The City of Venna - Caste Forum
=====> The City of Venna - Role Play
===> The Village of Troth
=====> Village of Troth - Roleplay
=====> Village of Troth - Feedback and Ideas
=====> Village of Troth - Events
===> Canjellne Woods
=====> Fort Selnar
=====> Events
===> The Isle of Tyros - Public Discussions
=====> Tyros Community Forum
===> City of Cyprianus
=====> General Discussions
=====> RP Stories and Logs
=====> Events
===> Three Moons Village
=====> Three Moons - Sim OOC & IC rules
=====> Three Moons - Role play story lines (daily life)
=====> Three Moons News
=====> Three Moons - Castes and Characters
=====> Kennels of Three Moons
=====> Three Moons Events
===> The Fortress City of Hochburg
=====> Hochburg Laws
=====> Recruiting by caste
=====> Hochburg Warriors
=====> Hochburg Kennels
=====> Hochburg - Character backgrounds
=====> Hochburg - General discussions
===> Thentis - Introduction, Laws and Council Decisions
=====> Thentis Role Play
=====> Thentis OOC Forum
=====> The Merchants of Thentis
===> The Gorean Information Center - G.I.C
===> The Village of Vatnfjel
=====> The Vatnfjel Story
=====> Vatnfjel Events
=====> Vatnfjel Roleplay
=====> Vatnfjel Feedback and Ideas
=====> The War Table
===> General Discussions
===> Gorean Vision - Treet TV Show
===> The City of Nyuki
=====> City of Nyuki Role Play
=====> City of Nyuki Events
=====> The Nyuki Chronicles
===> The Black Bastards of Gor
=====> Black Bastards of Gor - IC Forum
=====> Black Bastards of Gor - Kajira
=====> Black Bastards of Gor - Trainee
===> Port Cartius Falls
=====> Port Cartius Falls - Community Forum
=====> Port Cartius Falls - Residents
=====> Port Cartius Falls - Caste Forum
=====> Port Cartius Falls - Events
===> Iskander Pass - Gorean Roleplay Sim
=====> Iskander Pass News
=====> Iskander Pass Roleplay Journal
=====> Iskander Pass Discussion Forum
===> The City of Vonda - Introduction, Laws, and Discussions
=====> Scarlets of Vonda
=====> Kennels of Vonda
=====> Vonda Events
=======> Vonda OOC events
=====> Vonda Merchants
=====> Vonda Scribes
=====> Vonda lower Castes
=====> Vonda Herald
=====> Physcians of Vonda
===> The City of Venna
=====> City of Venna Information, Rules & Laws
=====> Rarii of Venna
=====> City of Venna IC and OOC Events
=====> Venna Roleplay
=====> City of Venna Kennels
===> Teslit on the Vosk
=====> Blue Caste of Teslit on the Vosk
=====> Green Caste of Teslit on the Vosk
=====> Red Caste of Teslit on the Vosk
=====> Merchant Caste of Teslit on the Vosk
=====> Kennels of Teslit on the Vosk
=====> Paga Tavern of Teslit on the Vosk
=====> Teslit on the Vosk Information and Events
=====> Teslit on the Vosk Roleplay
===> Wench
===> The City of Hochburg - Introduction, general statements, rules and news
=====> Rarii of Hochburg
=====> Kajirae of Hochburg
===> Heimdal Events and News
===> Saleria Merchant Camp Decress of the Council
=====> Saleria Merchant Camp Events and Informations
===> Oasis of Sand Sleen, Sand Sleen South and Wastelands of Sand Sleen
=====> Scribery: Laws, rules and chronicles
=====> Decisions of the Administration of Sand Sleen
=====> Wasteland South
=====> Taharian news and Events
===> Our Gorean Continent - OGC
=====> OGC Events
===> Avian Isle Citizen Forum-visitors welcome
===> CEC - Counter Earth Continent - Introduction, Rules and Council decisions
=====> CEC - Events
===> Ice Inlet
===> The Kel'zak
===> The Black Caste
=====> Black Caste Background
=====> Black Caste Recruitment
===> TFS - Roleplay
===> Marauders of Tyr's Fist
===> TFS Kennels
===> TFS Events
Loading...